Stump the Chump, Week Two


Latest Colts News

Schedule & Weekly Recap Archive

Personnel & Ticket Info

Team Rosters, Past and Present


Descendants of the Mayflower

Life Before Indianapolis

The Colts Record Book

Photo Gallery

Other Colts Sites

Visit the Trophy Case

Win the Award

Take the Survey

Colts Chat

Message Board

Other Colts Goodies

Sports Webrings and Sponsors

General Information about Indianapolis

Mike Devitt -- the Man, the Myth, the Managing Editor


coltslogo1.gif (4618 bytes)


Stump the Chump

Last Article Written: September 17, 1999

Stump the Chump, Week Two: Winning By the Skin of My Teeth

By Mike Devitt

What a way to start the season. At the end of 14 games last week, contestant Earl Phillips and I were left deadlocked at seven wins and seven losses apiece. Only after Monday night's game, a 38-21 win by the Miami Dolphins over the Denver Broncos, did The Chump emerge victorious and avoid starting out the season on a down note.

It doesn't get any easier for yours truly this week, however, as local radio personality Dave Wineland attempts to match wits with yours truly. A disc jockey-slash-production director at QMIX (107.3 FM) in Columbus, Indiana, and a Colts season ticket holder for the past 12 year, Dave's only hope -- according to his most recent e-mail -- is to "do better on my picks this week than I did last week."

That makes two of us.

So without further ado, it's time to see if Dave can stump the chump. Listed below are Dave's picks for each of this week's games, followed by my own picks and a small commentary on each game.

Good luck, Dave!

Sunday's Games

Indianapolis at New England
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Colts. New England may have won the last six games in this series, but this isn't the same Colts defense that gave up nearly 26 points per game those last six contests. And this isn't the same New England offense, with virtually no running game and a pair of offensive linemen (Zefross Moss and Heath Irwin) nursing injuries.

Arizona at Miami
Dave's pick:
Dolphins. Dave's first lock of the week.
My pick: Dolphins. Too many weapons on offense (and defense) for Miami, and not enough on either side for Arizona. Cards were lucky to escape with a 25-24 win over Eagles last week. They won't have such luck this week against the Dolphins, who have won 14 of their past 17 at home, including the past five home openers.


Cleveland at Tennessee
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Titans. Lock of the week. The Browns managed just 40 yards of total offense in their 1999 debut last week, getting whacked by the Steelers 43-0. It won't get any easier, as they play their first road game against a Titan defense that allowed just 69 rushing yards and had four takeaways. Welcome to the NFL, Tim Couch.

Denver at Kansas City
Dave's pick:
My pick: Chiefs. Look for Warren Moon to make his Kansas City debut some time in the second half. Also look for him to lead the Chiefs to an upset over a Bronco team that looked flat, out of sync, and could be working on the beginnings of a mutiny against head coach Mike Shanahan.

Green Bay at Detroit
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Lions. Who needs Barry Sanders? The Lions don't -- not at this point, anyway. Ron Rivers ran for a career-high 96 yards against the Seahawks last week. If he can duplicate that feat this week, it'll open up the passing lanes for Charlie Batch, who shredded the Pack for 218 yards and a pair of touchdowns when these teams met last October.

Jacksonville at Carolina
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Panthers. Upset of the week. Call this one a hunch. Jacksonville isn't as good as their 41-3 trouncing of the 49ers might suggest, and the Panthers aren't as bad as their 19-10 loss to the Saints indicates. Injuries to Bryce Paup, Bryan Schwartz and Fred Taylor certainly won't help Jacksonville's cause, either.

New Orleans at San Francisco
Dave's pick:
49ers. Dave's second lock of the week.
My pick:
49ers. Since 1986, San Francisco has never lost a game in which they lost the previous game by 14 points or more. Or to put it another way: Billie Joe Tolliver vs. Steve Young. Who would you pick?

Oakland at Minnesota
Dave's pick:
Vikings. Dave's third lock of the week.
My pick: Vikings. Between Cris Carter, Randy Moss, Charles Woodson and Erik Allen, this game will feature more trash talking than a Charles Barkley press conference. Look for Minnesota to open up the offense and exploit the passing game, which managed just 184 yards against the Falcons in last week's season opener.

Pittsburgh at Baltimore
Dave's pick:
My pick: Steelers. Last week, the Steelers destroyed the "new" Browns 43-0; this week, they get to do the same to the old Baltimore version. Hard to pick against a team that allowed just 40 yards of offense. Baltimore fans, this might be a good time to alphabetize your spice racks.

San Diego at Cincinnati
Dave's pick:
My pick: Chargers. Last year's top-ranked defense travels to Cynergy Field to take on a Bengal team that racked up 398 yards against the Titans in their season opener. Matchup of the day will be the Chargers' run defense against Cincinnati running back Corey Dillon. The Chargers didn't allow a 100-yard rusher in all of 1998; Dillon and the Bengals ran for 201 yards last Sunday.

Seattle at Chicago
Dave's pick:
My pick: Bears. Dog of the week. Hard to believe, but after one week, the Bears are still tied for first place in the NFC Central. They'll somehow manage to continue that streak this Sunday against a disappointing Seattle team that managed just 31 yards rushing and was thoroughly outplayed by the Lions in a 28-20 loss last weekend.

Tampa Bay at Philadelphia
Dave's pick:
Buccaneers. Dave's dog of the week.
My pick: Eagles. Merge the rosters of these two clubs and you might get a team that will win eight games this season. Tampa Bay's offense is the second coming of the 1991 Colts; Philadelphia's defense isn't far behind. When was the last time there was a scoreless tie in the NFL?

Washington at New York Giants
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Giants. Giants have a great defense (four INTs and five takeaways against Tampa Bay) but very little offense; Redskins have a powerful offense but no defense (Troy Aikman passed for career highs of 362 yards and five touchdowns last week). Giants get the edge at home. If Washington loses this game, look for new owner Daniel Snyder to cause heads to roll by the end of the month.

New York Jets at Buffalo
Dave's pick:
My pick:
Bills. Five words: Jets starting quarterback Rick Mirer. Need I say more?

Monday Night's Game

Atlanta at Dallas
Dave's pick:
Falcons. Dave's upset of the week.
My pick:
Falcons. If there's such a thing as a must-win game this early in the season, it's this Monday's game for Atlanta. A loss would drop the Falcons to 0-2, the same number of losses they had all season. With Chris Chandler's injury, look for Jamal Anderson to shoulder the brunt of the work on offense for Atlanta early on to set up the team's passing attack.

Last Week's Results
Earl Phillips: 7-8
The Chump 8-7

Season Totals to Date
Guest Prognosticators: 7-8 (46.7%)
The Chump: 8-7 (53.3%)

* * *

Mike Devitt writes the "Twelfth Man" column for the Indianapolis Star-News Online. He can be reached by telephone at (714) 841-9696, or by e-mail at

Back to the front page.